'Doubtful' fracking ban U-turn will contribute to UK's energy supply, says planner
Planning | News
Commenting on Prime Minister Liz Truss’ decision to lift the fracking ban, Brian Mullin, partner and head of planning consultancy Marrons Planning, said:
“The suggested mechanism for seeking planning permission for fracking appears to be very similar to the community consent mechanism required for onshore wind permissions. On the basis of past evidence, it is highly doubtful the fracking industry will meaningfully contribute to the energy supply in the UK.
“A 2015 Written Ministerial Statement (WMS) based on a Conservative Manifesto pledge to ‘change the law so local people have the final say on wind farm applications’ was followed by the somewhat toothless National Planning Policy Framework commitment to ‘approve the application if its impacts are, or can be made, acceptable.
“A footnote in the policy then states permission will be granted if, ‘following consultation, it can be demonstrated that the planning impacts identified by the affected local community have been fully addressed and the proposal has their backing.’
“To give an understanding of the effect of this mechanism, 16 new turbines were granted planning permission between 2016 and 2020 across England – representing a 96% decrease compared to the 435 turbines permitted for construction on 108 different sites between 2011 and 2015. Furthermore, 89% of all local planning authorities in England do not have areas identified as suitable for wind energy development in their local plan or in an adopted neighbourhood plan.
These figures illustrate that the 2015 WMS and subsequent planning policy effectively obliterated the onshore wind turbine industry in England. While the impacts of fracking are distinguishable from wind turbines, they are no less contentious. With lots of fear around environmental harm, this will be highly emotive for local communities. Whether a 25% decrease in energy bills is effective remains to be seen.
“If the government was serious about delivery, the evidence suggests that community consent would need to be removed as it demonstrably amounts to a moratorium for delivery. This would be a difficult political decision and would risk alienation of those responsible for putting Prime Minister Truss into office.”
Marrons is a multi-service development consultancy backed by the experience of working for local authorities, extensive market intel and connections across the industry - from planning offices and private landowners to housebuilders and retailers.
With expertise in Planning, Architecture, Design, Heritage and Economic Development, you can trust us to lead, protect and enhance the value of your land or building assets ensuring we turn your plans into reality.
Talk to our Planning experts
We act on behalf of a range of clients across the UK to deliver economic, social and environmental regeneration. Our specialists are here you turn your vision into reality.
Our Planning Team
Our Latest Planning News & Updates
Our Areas of Expertise
Whether you are looking for advice on an appeal for a major development scheme, or putting in an application for a house extension, we can help you navigate the best way forward.
Led by RIBA Chartered Architects, our Architects have wide-ranging experience in handling large scale projects through multi-disciplinary teams, often acting as project co-ordinators and design team leaders.
Our urban design team have a wealth of experience in both large scale urban development and detailed design and can help you make the most out of your land and provide a clear vision for your development.
Our heritage team proudly advocate for the role of heritage in sustainable place-shaping, and champion the value that heritage assets can bring to developments.
Our specialist team works with you to provide evidence that your land or planning development has commercial benefits, and positively impacts socio-economics in the wider community.